The graphemic representations that underlie spelling performance must encode not only the identities of the letters in a word, but also the positions of the letters. This study investigates how letter position information is represented. We present evidence from two dysgraphic individuals, CM and LSS, who perseverate letters when spelling: that is, letters from previous spelling responses intrude into subsequent responses. The perseverated letters appear more often than expected by chance in the same position in the previous and subsequent responses. We used these errors to address the question of how letter position is represented in spelling. In a series of analyses we determined how often the perseveration errors produced maintain position as defined by a number of alternative theories of letter position encoding proposed in the literature. The analyses provide strong evidence that the grapheme representations used in spelling encode letter position such that position is represented in a graded manner based on distance from both edges of the word.
Keywordsletter position coding; dysgraphia; spelling; letter perseveration errors; orthographic processing Many cognitive functions require the ability to represent and process sequences of items or events. Sequence information is essential, for example, in recalling a telephone number, reasoning about causes and effects, navigating a route through an environment, or producing a sentence. As Karl Lashley pointed out more than 50 years ago in The problem of serial order in behavior (Lashley, 1951), the question of how the brain represents and processes ordered sequences is far from trivial; and this question remains a central concern for research in a variety of cognitive domains (e.g., working memory: Henson, 1998; motor control: Bullock, 2004; reading: Grainger & Whitney, 2004; music performance: Palmer, 2005; spoken language production: Dell, Burger & Svec, 1997).This article addresses the serial order issue in the context of spelling. Spelling a word requires not only information about the identities of the letters in the word, but also information about the ordering of those letters. This ordering information could be encoded in a variety of ways. In the word PENCIL, for example, the letter E could be represented as the second letter in the word, the letter five positions from the end of the word, the letter in the nucleus of the first (orthographic) syllable, or the letter that follows P and precedes N. In each case the E's position * Corresponding author: Department of Cognitive Science, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 North Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, Tel: 410-516-7625, Fax: 410-516-8020, fischerbaum@cogsci.jhu.edu. Publisher's Disclaimer: This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final citable form....